Hunter Sibley

High School Career

Hunter Sibley attended Millville Senior High School in New Jersey, the alma mater of MLB superstar Mike Trout. While at Millville, he was honored with Trout’s retired #1 jersey and served as captain of the varsity baseball team. Sibley was named 1st team all Cape Atlantic league as well as ranked the 14th-best shortstop in New Jersey for the Class of 2018 by Perfect Game. He also earned recognition as a 2017 Perfect Game Preseason Underclass All-American Honorable Mention.

College Career

Iona College (Division I – New Rochelle, NY)
Sibley began his collegiate career at Iona College, where he made an immediate impact as a freshman:
•    Named to the All-MAAC Rookie Team
•    Featured by D1Baseball.com as a Top Future Prospect in his draft class
•    Recorded a standout performance on May 6th vs. Quinnipiac, striking out 9 batters in 6 innings—the most by an Iona pitcher in a six-inning start since 2004

His freshman season was ultimately cut short by the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic.

⸻

Coastal Carolina University (Division I – Conway, SC)
Sibley transferred to Coastal Carolina, a perennial top-25 program in Division I baseball. Though used in a limited bullpen role, he made notable contributions:
•    Appeared in 6 games, posting a 2.45 ERA
•    Earned Head Coach Gary Gilmore’s 1,000th career win
•    Picked up his first CCU victory against Texas State

⸻

Arcadia University (Division III – Glenside, PA)
Seeking increased playing time and a larger role, Sibley completed his college career at Arcadia University, where he became a crucial part of the team’s success:
•    Contributed to two conference championship seasons, including a 40–9 team overall record
•    Delivered a signature performance with 7.0 shutout innings and 9 strikeouts against Misericordia University

College

Iona, Coastal Carolina, Arcadia

Positions Played in College

RHP

Accolades

2x MAC Champion